Apple said Epic’s Fortnight payment plan is “theft, period.”

Apple has been aggressive in the moment Its constant legal battles with Epic Games On the iOS version of Fornite. In A comprehensive proposal was filed Tuesday afternoon, Apple defended itself against Epic’s legal allegations while also making allegations Fornite Breach of contract and apparent theft in countersuit.

Although Paul writes, “Epic presents itself as the modern corporate Robin Hood, in fact it is a multi-billion dollar venture that simply does not want to pay anything for the tremendous value it gets from the Five Stores,” writes Paul.

Who pays for?

In its own legal filings, Epic explores the right to provide what it calls a “competitive payment process on iOS” by going around the built-in purchase system in the iOS app store. Epic tried to do this unilaterally last month Adding the Discounted Epic Direct Payments option to the iOS version of Fornite, A move or lead Apple will completely block Epic from the Pal App Store.

In addition to breach of contract, Apple Paul says in its motion that Epic’s addition to direct payments was a “Trojan horse” that is “slightly more than a thief.” Using the “hotfix” update method, deliberately hidden from the general app store review process, Apple says Epic is seeking to enjoy all the benefits of Apple’s iOS platform and related services, while [lining] Epic’s pockets at Epic’s expense. “

Later in the motion, Apple Paul says the introduction of direct payments in Epic’s game is “stealing, period.”

Epic has gladly agreed to the terms of Apple’s agreement to access iOS development since 2008, Apple writes, earning more than 600 600 million from sales of the App Store during that period. The fact that Epic will no longer accept the deal “does not provide Epic with the cover to breach binding agreements, long-term business partner, pocket commission that is properly Apple’s moment, and then asks this court to take Judicial Sledgehammer on one of them.” “The most innovative business platform of the 21st century simply because it doesn’t maximize epic revenue,” Apple writes.

IcPal adds that the percent0 percent iOS cell commission that APIC tried to get around is more than a simple payment processing fee. Instead, the fees reflect the immense value of the App Store, which is more than the sum of its parts and includes Apple’s technology, tools, software for application development and testing, marketing efforts, platinum-level customer service and distribution to developers. “Apps and digital content.” It includes more than 150,000 APIs built by Apple to facilitate iOS development, the company writes. Metal Graphics API Epic has praised itself in the past.

Apple wrote in a letter to Epic in July in response to Epic’s request, “The App Store is not a public utility.” Epic has no right to cut, “Apple and the App Store offer without paying a penny,” the company said.

No, you can’t have your own app store

In Its own recent filings, Epic says it “does not want to force Apple Pal to provide free delivery and processing services, nor does it want Epic to enjoy Apple Paul’s services without paying them.”

Instead, Epic says it wants the freedom not to use Apple’s App Store or IAP, and instead uses and offers competitive services only on Apple’s hardware. It can do on Windows PC. That’s not possible, though, according to Epic, Apple has a monopoly on the market for all iOS software.

Apple Paul directly states in its motion that it “does not have a monopoly on any relevant market” and that “competition is fierce at every level, both inside and outside the App Store: for devices, platforms and personal applications.” More than that, however, Apple Pal says that all storage iOS purchases go through the app store infrastructure, “is essential to ensure that iOS apps meet Apple Paul’s high standards for privacy, security, content and quality.”

Apple cites Epic’s own example on other platforms as proof of this requirement. When Epic started Distribute the Android version of Fornite Independently in 2018, Apple Paul writes that “Immediately appeared sites that did not even advertise Android. Fornite Also distributed malware in the game. Apple also quoted Play Security Vulnerabilities Its independently distributed Android version requires its iOS protection as evidence.

Although Paul writes that, “Apple does not leave Paul on any developer to keep the iOS platform safe and secure, especially since Epic has shown that it cannot be assigned this kind of responsibility.”

In addition to compensation and punitive damages for breach of contract and other related violations, Apple seeks to prevent Paul Epic from continuing to use its own external payment processing method. Existing copies of the iOS version of Fornite Or future applications.